Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin | 코인긱스

Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin


Strong Evidence Shows a Single Miner Mined More Than a Million Bitcoin

On April 16, RSK Labs chief scientist Sergio Demián Lerner published a new research study concerning the earliest blocks mined on the Bitcoin network. The report concerning one of Bitcoin’s earliest miners provides strong evidence to suggest that a single miner processed 22,000 blocks. Additionally, Lerner has released a new website called Satoshi Blocks that aims to help crypto enthusiasts visualize mining during the protocol’s earliest days.

Also read: Are You Ready for What Happens If Satoshi’s Coins Move?

New Data Stemming from Bitcoin’s Earliest Miners Hardens Prior Evidence

Years ago, independent researcher and cryptographer Sergio Demián Lerner released one of the most in-depth studies concerning Bitcoin’s earliest mining periods. According to his first study published on April 17, 2013, the vast majority of the initial BTC mined was done by a single miner. Moreover, Lerner produced data sets from his blockchain analysis that tracked the extranonce fields within the coinbase field stemming from the coinbase transactions themselves. At the time Lerner estimated that the miner was able to gather precisely 1,814,400 BTC. In addition to this large number of mined coins, 63% of those coins, or 1.1 million, have never been spent since the day they were created.

Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin

Fast forward to six years later and Lerner has published another rigorous study that provides an even stronger argument that backs his prior claims. The latest paper, called “The Return of the Deniers and the Revenge of Patoshi,” at first discusses Lerner’s original study and how he originally came to his previous conclusion. Lerner detailed how he found the information in the extranonce field and how certain flaws revealed information in a “non-privacy preserving way.”

Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin
Lerner calls these patterns shown as blue lines the ‘Patoshi pattern’ after identifying a single miner who accumulated about 1.1M bitcoins during 2009-2010. The Patoshi pattern (blue) and other miner patterns (green). The data can be visualized on Lerner’s new website

Lerner’s paper then discusses the single miner who has been dubbed ‘Patoshi’ and describes how he was able to find the miner’s pattern. Lerner explains how a few people have accepted the existence of the Patoshi pattern, a few years on, yet believe multiple miners may have been synchronized or there was some form of an early mining pool in place since the genesis block. Lerner debunks these arguments with many reasons and by explaining various factors including:

  • 99.9% of all Patoshi blocks are unspent.
  • Each Patoshi block “links” to a block in the pattern set, but not to any of the remaining blocks.
  • There are some time intervals where the Patoshi pattern interrupts abruptly.
  • Mining pools were invented several years later.
  • Mining pools were created to reduce reward variance due to the low individual probability of solving a block, but during 2009 single miners could easily solve blocks frequently.

By the end of 2013, Lerner said he had found proof “beyond any doubt, that the pattern was real, using a completely different method.” His latest study describes how he discovered that all of the blocks mined by Patoshi were identifiable by a depleted range of nonces used in processed blocks to a specific range. From 2014 to early 2019, Lerner didn’t have much more to add to his prior research and there were a few other studies published recently that suggest Patoshi only mined around 700,000 coins. However, Lerner’s latest study “proves with overwhelming probability” that a single miner extracted all of the coins in his Patoshi pattern, which is well over a million BTC. The researcher’s new argument is based on computer clocks because even in the early days miners used a local computer’s clock to timestamp blocks after processing them.

Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin
According to Lerner, Patoshi paused mining for 10 days. Lerner also suggests that the miner called ‘Patoshi’ gave away approximately 550 BTC to other people in the form of donations

“If you’ve studied the Bitcoin protocol, you’ll know that block timestamps are not necessarily monotonically increasing,” Lerner writes. “This is true from the Bitcoin source code 0.1.0 to the latest version of Bitcoin Core that had an internal miner (before mining pools were created).”

Clocks and Timestamps

Some of the latest evidence Lerner provides also concerns why he strongly believes the single miner extracted close to 1.1M coins, which is even more than the initial 1M BTC discovered by Lerner years ago. For instance, Lerner states that “computer clocks can be unsynchronized from each other,” “timestamps were not updated continuously during mining,” and “block timestamps are adjusted by the Bitcoin software to match the median time of the peers that are connected to a node.” Because of these reasons, the study notes that the same computer will almost never reverse its own timestamps and “the delta between inverted block timestamps indirectly measures the hashrate of the parent block miner.”

Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin
Lerner’s study shows a few cases of timestamp inversions.

“There are no time inversions between Patoshi blocks — Zero — This result is very relevant considering the Patoshi blocks account for 43% of all the blocks in the first 50k. I’m open to considering other explanations, but for me, this can only mean one thing — There is a single PC clock whose time is stamped in the Patoshi blocks.” Lerner’s paper continues:

A single software that controls how block templates are created — A single miner.

The RSK Labs chief scientist concludes that there is evidence that links the Patoshi patterns to Satoshi but he prefers to stop there and “leave Patoshi alone once for all.” Lerner believes the evidence he provided is reliable but he expects more people to deny the information in forums. Lerner also infers that he has discovered a more precise figure and coded a more accurate pattern-following algorithm which can be viewed on his new site

Do you think the Patoshi pattern belongs to Satoshi? Do you believe a single miner mined over 1.1 million BTC during the network’s earliest days? Let us know what you think about this subject in the comments section below.

Image credits: Shutterstock, Sergio Demián Lerner’s blog, Pixabay, and

Not up to date on the news? Listen to This Week in Bitcoin, a podcast updated each Friday.

The post Strong Evidence Suggests a Single Entity Mined More Than 1 Million Bitcoin appeared first on Bitcoin News.

source :



‘에이코인(ACOIN)” 은 전 세계 오프라인 금거래 시장에서 금의 안전한 거래를 위해 사용하는 프로토콜 암호화폐이며, 코인월드 에이코인(ACO) 전용마켓 오픈 예정
한미중일 4개국 합자투자로 탄생한 코인월드, ‘에이코인'(ACOIN) 국내 최초 상장 협의중으로 4/16 사전 예약 실시
Coin world, ACOIN listing Discussion
Cryptocurrency exchange coin world, advance booking on next 16th

No comments

格林威治大学毕业证英国UG成绩单首选95270640微Q办理UG真实学历认证UG毕业证文凭学士学位证UG教育部认证大学University of Greenwich

文凭学历认证,薇Q/95270640、文凭毕业证办理、大学毕业证成绩单办理、办理各大学文凭毕业证、学历认证英国留学生买毕业证#美国毕业证#美国文凭#澳洲文凭毕业证#英国毕业证#英国文凭#加拿大文凭毕业证#新西兰毕业证#法国毕业证#德国毕业证#铸就十年,十年品质!信誉!实体公司!可以视频看办公环境样板,如需办理真实可查学历认证 一、如果您是以下情况,我们都能竭诚为您解决实际问题!1、回国时间很长,忘记办理;2、企事业单位必须要求办理的;3、面对父母的压力,希望尽快拿到;4、不清楚流程以及材料该如何准备;5、回国马上就要找工作,办给用人单位看;6、在校期间,因各种原因未能顺利毕业,拿不到官方毕业证;二、业务范围:★、全套服务:毕业证、成绩单、真实回国人员证明、真实教育部认证。让您回国发展信心十足!★、真实教育部学历学位认证;(一对一专业服务,可全程监控跟踪进度)★、真实使馆认证,可以通过大使馆查询确认;(即教育部留服认证,不成功不收费)★、毕业证、成绩单等材料,从防伪到印刷、水印到钢印烫金,高精仿度都是跟学校原版100%相同的;(敬请放心使用)★、可以提供钢印、水印、烫金、激光防伪、凹凸版、最新版的毕业证、百分之百让您绝对满意、★、印刷,DHL快递毕业证、成绩单7个工作日,真实大使馆教育部认证1个月。为了达到高水准高效率, 三、主营国家:澳大学利亚、英国、美国、德国、法国、加拿大学、俄罗斯、新西兰、新加坡、日本、爱尔兰、韩国、马来西亚、奥地利、荷兰、比利时、意大学利、丹麦、瑞士、瑞典、芬兰、挪威、南非、泰国、印度、蒙古、朝鲜、乌克兰、白俄罗斯、哈萨克斯坦、乌兹别克斯坦、吉尔吉斯斯坦、埃及、菲律宾和中国香港、澳门特别行政区以及台湾地区四、业务类型:大學文凭,大学专文凭,本科文凭,专科文凭,硕士文凭,博士文凭,教育部真实国外学历学位认证书,公证,大学使馆留学回国人员证明 薇Q/95270640、文凭毕业证办理、大学毕业证成绩单办理、办理各大学文凭毕业证、学历认证英国留学生买毕业证#美国毕业证#美国文凭#澳洲文凭毕业证#英国毕业证#英国文凭#加拿大文凭毕业证#新西兰毕业证#法国毕业证#德国毕业证# Source: 格林威治大学毕业证英国UG成绩单首选95270640微Q办理UG真实学历认证UG毕业证文凭学士学位证UG教育部认证大学University of Greenwich