Federal Judge Rules Cryptocurrency MBC Is a Commodity | 코인긱스

Federal Judge Rules Cryptocurrency MBC Is a Commodity


Federal Judge Rules Cryptocurrency MBC Is a Commodity

In a landmark case for the cryptocurrency industry, a federal judge has ruled that a cryptocurrency caught in the midst of a lawsuit is a commodity, court documents reveal.

U.S. District Judge for Massachusetts Rya Zobel has decided that the suit’s prosecuting party — the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) — can proceed with its case against My Big Coin Pay Inc. as its cryptocurrency My Big Coin (MBC) does not fall into the category of a security.

My Big Coin was founded in December of 2013. Allegedly based in Wyoming, the company offers its own digital wallet to store cryptocurrencies and a digital exchange to trade them. My Big Coin began selling its own currency — MBC — through an initial coin offering (ICO) and made approximately $6 million from 28 separate investors by promising 1 percent interest per year to investors that kept their wallets open.

The CFTC claims that the ICO has all the same behavior and qualities of a Ponzi scheme. They allege that the company is based in Las Vegas, not Wyoming, and that owners Randall Crater of New York and Mark Gillespie of Michigan used customer funds to purchase expensive items for themselves.

In addition, the CFTC believes the money was raised through several false claims, including that MBC was backed by gold and traded across several different exchanges, and that My Big Coin had recently struck a partnership with MasterCard.

Charges were filed back in January of 2018. The company’s accounts were frozen, and executives were blocked from accessing them. They were also prohibited from disposing of any financial records.

According to court documents, Judge Zobel believes that MBC classifies as a commodity because it is a cryptocurrency like bitcoin:

“The amended complaint alleges that My Big Coin is a virtual currency, and it is undisputed that there is futures trading in virtual currencies (specifically involving bitcoin). That is sufficient, especially at the pleading stage, for plaintiff to allege that My Big Coin is a ‘commodity’ under the [Commodity Exchange] Act.”

Defending lawyer for My Big Coin Katherine Cooper expressed her disappointment in the decision and continues to argue that the CFTC holds no precedence. In the court documents, she argues that “contracts for future delivery” are indisputably not “dealt in” My Big Coin. Thus, the currency cannot be classified as a commodity under the ECA.

“My Big Coin does not have future contracts or derivatives trading to it,” she asserts. “It is not a commodity. Now that we are moving past the motion-to-dismiss phase of the case, we look forward to challenging the CFTC’s ability to prove many of the factual allegations in the complaint. Among those factual allegations are those which speak to the relatedness of bitcoin and My Big Coin, and, therefore, the CFTC’s jurisdiction,” she said.

Defining crypto tokens has not always been an easy feat for U.S. lawmakers. Recently, federal judge Raymond Dearie in New York invoked decades-old securities laws to decide that two separate ICOs, one for REcoin and one for Diamond, classified as securities. Both projects were run by Maksim Zaslavskiy who claimed that REcoin was backed by real estate and that Diamond was backed by real diamonds. Neither entity backed the coins, and Zaslavskiy has been charged with two counts of securities fraud.

Dearie stated that the ICOs in question were “investment contracts” according to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Howey Test, which states that a transaction is an investment contract if a person invests money in a “common enterprise and is led to expect profits solely from the efforts of the promoter or a third party.”

Dearie asserts customers expected returns on their investments and even referenced the DAO Report in his decision, which was issued in July of 2017 and explains that all tokens sold on Ethereum-based platforms, like both REcoin and Diamond, were securities.

Dearie, however, stated that the laws were meant to be interpreted flexibly and that not all ICOs could be considered securities. The same could be said for the My Big Coin case, as the classification of the cryptocurrency as a commodity is confined to the case at hand and does not extend to other crypto assets currently available on the market.

Image credit: By M2545 – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0

This article originally appeared on Bitcoin Magazine.


No comments

办科罗拉多州立大学学历认证Q+微993398773【美国毕业证文凭】办理CSU毕业证成绩单*教育部认证*本科文凭硕士学历原版制作*海外假学历学位证书购买 Colorado State Universi

办科罗拉多州立大学学历认证Q+微993398773【美国毕业证文凭】办理CSU毕业证成绩单*教育部认证*本科文凭硕士学历原版制作*海外假学历学位证书购买 Colorado State University【查看点击网页快照】十五年致力于帮助留学生解决无法毕业,无法认证真实的难题;并帮助留学生制作美国,加拿大,澳洲,英国大学毕业证成绩单 ,大学文凭,办理留信认证,成绩单,真实认证、以及回国所需的真实学位真实认证。代办国外(海外)澳洲英国 加拿大 韩国 美国 新西兰 等各大学毕业证,修改成绩单分数,学历认证,文凭,diploma,degree 真实认证.海外回囯的同学定制毕业证、真实认证、毕业证、学位证书、使馆公证、囯外真实学位认证、使馆留学回囯人员证明、录取通知书、Offer、在读证明、雅思托福成绩单、网上存档永久可查!→ ★如果您在英、加、美、澳、欧洲等留学过程中或回国后遇到以下问题: ◇在校期间,因各种原因未能顺利毕业,拿不到官方毕业证 ◇面对父母的压力,希望尽快拿到; ◇不清楚认证流程以及材料该如何准备; ◇回.国时间很长,忘记办理; ◇回.国马上就要找工作,办给用人单位看;   ◇企事业单位必须要求办理的 ◇需要报考公务员、购买免税车、落转户口 ◇申请留学生创业基金 → ★远洋教育为您做的是: ◆办理真实使馆公证(即留学回国人员证明,不成功不收费!!!)  ◆办理教育部国外学位学历认证。(网上可查、永久存档、快速稳妥,回国发展,考公务员,落户,进国企,外企,创业,无忧愁)  ◆办理各国各大学(世界名校一对一专业服务,可全程监控跟踪进度) ...